I figured out that if I do hand lettering using a dull pencil and then invert it to white in Photoshop over a chalkboard background, it looks like real chalk lettering. Here are a few comps I just finished for Michaels Arts & Crafts showing the before (pencil) and after (chalk).
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/796d0/796d04efef31f0270bcfb03fa7f64271d9618c5e" alt="HandletteredChalk"